Saturday, May 30, 2015

Unmasking the Elephant

I just saw a link to a video of a middle aged woman in tears of joy with the following caption:

"HIGH SCHOOL SENIORS SACRIFICE CLASS TRIP TO DONATE TO PRINCIPAL'S CANCER CARE  "
A very brief summary follows:

" Principal Courtney Vashaw of Bethlehem's Profile School for both junior and high school students has worked hard to teach her students about caring for others and being compassionate across her seven-year tenure, but never expected that the lesson in kindness would come back to benefit her.  Vashaw told her students that she had been diagnosed with a rare cancer of the soft tissue earlier this month, explaining that the illness would put her out of school for some time.
The heartbreaking news came just as the seniors were about to leave for their four-day senior trip to Rydin' Hi Ranch in New York. Though after hearing of their principal's health concerns, the seniors took a vote and unanimously decided to donate the trip's nearly $8,000 expenses to Vashaw as a gift" Vashaw was overwhelmed by the generosity of her students, and immediately brought to tears. "It is very hard for me to accept help, and I have no idea what to say to you," said Vashaw." 

The link below will take you to the actual story.


     This is genuinely touching and I applaud the kids who did it. The "elephant in the room" however, is the unasked or answered question:

"Why in the world does a fully employed School administrator(or anyone else in America, for that matter) need a handout to obtain medical treatment?"

         There are two issues here: First - Just how shitty is the school district's healthcare insurance, that it wouldn't completely cover this illness? Second: When will we as a nation get our heads out of our collective asses, look at the entire rest of the industrialized nations of the world and objectively ask why they are (all, except Portugal and Mexico) as a nation happier with their health care than US consumers. (fact, in survey after survey! FACT!). Ascertaining that, why do all those nations spend a far smaller of GDP to provide said health care?

       I would hazard a guess that medication constitutes a huge part of whatever this person's cost factor is, yet while the average US corporation earns just under 4% annual profit, several major Pharma corporations regularly earn over 30%, some of which is spent lobbying Congress against healthcare reform! Of course her cancer medication will be expensive - in the United States. Here's an example which illustrates one of the shames of US policy: In Spain, an average 30 day prescription for Nexium costs the equvalent of $18. US consumer, same drug, same amount - averages $187!

        Prescription drug pricing in the United States is unregulated, which means that Big Pharma can charge whatever it wants for prescription drugs. Executives at America’s top pharmaceutical companies , if asked about these high priced meds and the high costs of most prescription drugs, will tell you that high and increasing drug prices are needed to sustain research and development efforts. In truth (remember truth?) numerous studies have debunked those claims. One study, by the group Families USA, found that America’s major drug companies are spending more than twice as much on marketing, advertising and administration than they do on research and development.

        Again, an easy example - Vioxx (2 "x"s must be special), which was pulled from distribution by the FDA after 5 years in the market, cost Merck by their own inflated numbers, about $1 billion in development. They recouped double that in the first year, and by the time the FDA pulled the plug, had made an additional $4.5 billion in pure profit on this medication, which was pulled from the formulary because of high heart attack and stroke risk.
Another financial analysis found, not surprisingly, that the total profits of all of America’s top pharmaceutical companies far exceed their research and development costs.

     So, bravo to these school kids, who decided to forgo their senior trip to help their principal. Shame on a system which allows this sort of thing to happen.  The truth about healthcare here and in the rest of the world is as close as a Google search. Screw the Congressional and industry mouthpieces for Big Pharma - educate yourselves. The truth is out there!


No comments:

Post a Comment