More Than Anybody
OK, we know he lies whenever he speaks, but there are two
which keep resounding as desperate hopefulness that if he says them often enough,
they will become true.
The first is Trump’s
constant repetition that he and/or his administration was responsible for enacting
the Veteran’s Choice bill which allowed veterans in the VA system who live more
than 40 miles from a clinic to opt to use private health care providers. This
resounds with those too ignorant or, more likely, too naïve to simply Google it.
Doing so would reveal the following: President Obama signed the Veteran’s Choice
Act into law in October 2014. Read it again. Trump claimed this in June, 2018: “So
it’s now my great honor to sign the VA Mission Act, or as we all know it,
the Choice Act, and to make Veterans Choice the permanent law of our
great country,” the president said, standing in the Rose Garden. “And nobody
deserves it more than our veterans.”
The germ of
truth is that the original Choice bill mandated that within 40 miles of a
clinic, the veteran would be required to use VA facilities. The Mission Act did
not, as Trump has implied too often to count, initiate, or allow a “new”
concept. What it did do, in what amounts to a valentine to private
health care providers, was to ease the 40-mile restriction in some cases. The
other part of that is that the original Choice Act, passed by a hostile GOP controlled Congress, badly underfunded the original act. The Mission Act, passed by the Trump crony US
Senate, in the main, simply added appropriate funding and several other
administrative measures. Choice was already the “law of the land” halfway
through Obama’s second term.
Even more
insulting, and to a much larger segment of the population, are statements such
as: “My Administration has done more for the Black Community than any President
since Abraham Lincoln.” This analogy, in almost always the same words, has been
reiterated numerous times, usually when he can’t honestly answer a legitimate
query posed by another individual. He even used it with Bob Woodward during
interviews for his recent Book, Rage. It’s another sort of “but whaddabout” response.
You know as in “Mr. President how do you respond to charges that you encourage
white supremacists?” and Trump says, “But, I’ve done more etc.…”
We’ve all seen
and heard him do it. He said during the recent debate that he was, “The least
racist person in the room!” Of course, the best laboratory in which to prove or
disprove this is the public acts and statements of the man himself, Accordingly
I’ve saved my readers the trouble of research and found several relevant examples,
either quotes or anecdotal observations.
·
“Black guys counting my money! I hate it. The
only kind of people I want counting my money are short guys that wear yarmulkes
every day. … I think that the guy is lazy. And it’s probably not his fault,
because laziness is a trait in blacks. It really is, I believe that. It’s not
anything they can control.” (commenting on a casino employee)
·
“When Donald and Ivana came to the casino, the
bosses would order all the black people off the floor,” (a former employee of
Trump’s Castle, in Atlantic City, New Jersey) verified by eyewitness reporter
several times
·
“Who the f*** knows? I mean, really, who knows
how much the Japs will pay for Manhattan property these days?” (Pre-White
House)
·
By June 2020, two hundred of Trump's judicial
nominees had been confirmed to lifetime appointments as Article III judges.
Neither of his two Supreme Court judges, none of his 53 appeals court judges,
and neither of his two Court of International Trade judges are Black. One is
Latino American, and seven are Asian Pacific American. The remainder of Trump's
200 judicial appointments were to district courts. Nine of these 143 district
court judges (6%) are Black
·
August 2019, Trump's anti-immigrant rhetoric was
widely criticized, especially remarks regarding Hispanics and his repeated
warnings about an immigrant "invasion", the same wording used by the
El Paso shooter in his anti-immigrant manifesto in which he wrote, "this
attack is a response to the Hispanic invasion of Texas." Representative
Veronica Escobar, whose district includes a large part of the city, said
"Words have consequences. The president has made my community and my
people the enemy. He has told the country that we are people to be feared,
people to be hated." Presidential candidate Beto O'Rourke, who is from El
Paso, stated: "Anyone who is surprised is part of this problem right
now—including members of the media who ask, 'Hey Beto, do you think the
president is racist?' Well, Jesus Christ, of course he's racist. He's been
racist from day one.
While I doubt that these examples
are revelations to most sentient Americans, it is worth noting that this skewed
sense of social reality was learned early from Fred Trump Sr. The Trump paterfamilias
got rich using Government loans to build apartment housing, primarily in
Brooklyn and to some extent in in New Jersey in the post war housing shortage. While
all taxpayers’ money theoretically contributed to the financial backing with
which Fred Sr. built this empire, eventually totaling more than 27,000
apartments and a few row houses, only white taxpayers were allowed to live in
it.
The usual process was to
simply claim there were “no vacancies” when persons of color applied. This came
to a head when a white operative for the NY Housing authority applied
immediately after an earlier operative (a person of color) had been denied on
the grounds of "no vacancy". The white applicant was assured there were several
apartments available and offered a tour. The resultant federal lawsuit was
settled out of court with a large fine. Donald’s statement to an attorney during
the prolonged litigation was, “You know, you don’t want to live with them
either.”
In the present this has continued
in much the same vein. The Trump administration reversed the 2015 Obama
administration Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing Rule which was enacted to
promote equal housing opportunities and level the playing field so that
neighborhoods provided equal opportunities for all. (making “red-lining” and
deed restrictions based on race or social intangibles, other than ability to
afford the house, illegal) Eugene
Robinson called Trump's decision "Maybe be the most nakedly racist appeal
to White voters that I’ve seen since the days of segregationist state leaders
such as Alabama’s George Wallace and Georgia’s Lester Maddox.”
Apparently, in Trump World, a
suburb is the kind of community where great Americans live because “we've”
limited it. He thinks it's just straight-up racializing this idea of housing,
after all he and his dad did it in the 1970s. The Trump position seems to be, “I’m
going to tell you that these people are good, (or some version of “us versus
them.”) We are, the good people; they’re the bad people and we have to keep
them out to keep our greatness.”'
Bob Woodward, in “Rage”
describes a recorded interview with Trump in which he (Woodward) talks about
white privilege. Woodward asked Trump if he was working to "understand the
anger and the pain, particularly, Black people feel in this country.” Trump
replied “No. You really drank the Kool-Aid, didn’t you? Just listen to you.
Wow. No, I don’t feel that at all.
Admittedly, all the above
mentioned examples could be subject to the interpretation of the reader, so let’s
look at the “Done more for Blacks than anyone since Lincoln” mantra which is
Trump’s almost daily fallback when pressed on the issue of his racism. Let’s
look it in terms of concrete “civil rights” activities or legislation.
Obviously, one could look at
actual positive legislative initiatives which have been the product of the Trump
administration’s efforts in the field. Unfortunately, that’s not possible
because there have been none. Actually, Since Trump took office in January
2017, his administration has worked aggressively to turn back the clock on America's civil and human rights progress. I will limit this to just a few of the more blatant
examples of this retrograde approach:
·
On February 22, 2017, the Justice Department’s
Civil Rights Division and the Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights
jointly rescinded Title IX guidance clarifying protections under the law for
transgender students.
·
On October 2, 2017, ED Sec. DeVos rescinded 72
guidance documents outlining the rights of students with disabilities.
·
On November 16, 2017, the Federal Communications
Commission voted to gut Lifeline, the program dedicated to bringing phone and
internet service within reach for people of color, low-income people, seniors,
veterans, and people with disabilities, with particularly egregious
consequences for tribal areas. (“Red” persons!)
·
On June 18, 2018, Nikki Haley, the U.S.
Ambassador to the United Nations, announced that the United States was
withdrawing from the UN Human Rights Council.
·
On October 1, 2018, a policy change at the Department of State
took effect saying that the Trump administration would no longer issue family
visas to same-sex domestic partners of foreign diplomats or employees of
international organizations who work in the United States.
·
On May 22, 2019, the Department of Housing and
Urban Development proposed changing the Obama-era Equal Access Rule to allow
homeless shelters to deny access based on a person’s gender identity.
This is, believe, me, but a tiny
smattering of the body of retrograde civil rights actions taken either by Trump
executive order or cabinet level officials with his approval. I can find not
one piece of legislation signed by Trump which furthers civil rights for anyone
On the other hand, re: the “more
than anyone” claim, Consider the Civil Rights legislation personally pushed,
especially in the Senate and signed into law by Lyndon Johnson. The Civil Rights
Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965 alone are momentous. Add to that Medicare
and Medicaid and it’s obvious Trump is delusional, Sadly, LBJ, a flawed man himself,
committed to US military engagement in South East Asia which, for many
overshadowed his Civil Rights record.
It
is worth mentioning, in closing that, in 2013, the USSC declared the Voting Rights act defunct as
written because the data regarding various
voter suppression tactics, on which the original law was based, was 40 years
old. The late Ruth Bader Ginsburg phrased her dissent thus: “Throwing out the
act when it has worked and is continuing to work to stop discriminatory changes
is like throwing away your umbrella in a rainstorm because you are not getting
wet." Her words were prophetic, since Harry Reid and John Boehner, with both
houses under GOP control, stifled any attempt to rewrite and repass. As a result,
within three years after the ruling, 868 polling places had been closed down. Within
five years, in 2018, nearly a thousand polling places had been closed in the
country, with many of the closed polling places in predominantly African
American counties. Trump’s ongoing attempts at voter suppression are proof
positive of his racial bias, present since he was a boy.