A letter in today’s paper
criticized Matt Lauer for his handling of the Paula Deen interview
(when she finally showed up) , branded all of those who are disappointed with
Ms. Deen as “Lauerites” and slapped the nonsense
syllables “liberal agenda” on top of it
all. I, like many, was and am a Paula Deen fan. I am now a disappointed one, I
must admit. Ms. Deen conquered a nasty divorce, and agoraphobia, but the thing
she couldn’t overcome is the thing which has apparently brought her low.
Let’s break it down. Whether or not
you feel Ms Deen deserves forgiveness
and another chance to continue making the multi millions her self-created
empire earns is a personal decision. There are however, several points to be made which bear notice. First is that, like many modern media darlings, there are
those idolatrous fans for whom Ms. Deen,
like Kim, Martha, Amanda, et. al. can do no wrong, so any negative opinion regarding her (their) actions doesn’t count. Second
is that regardless of Ms. Deen’s central Georgia upbringing and the accompanying
racial intolerance she no doubt learned at
home, she is now 65 years old, lived through the Civil rights movement, and as
a rational adult had two choices. She
could have seen the error of her ways
and discontinue using hate speech regardless of her upbringing or alternately, continue to harbor those prejudices
and public behaviors based on them. In light of her position as the public persona
of a financial empire, it was unfortunate that she apparently
chose the latter option.
The larger issue for me ( since Paula
Deen can retire with a mountain of money and slide into memory) is the letter
writer’s use of the phrase “liberal agenda.”
The number of corporations who rushed to cut ties with Ms. Deen immediately are indicative of how little
concern she applied before speaking her mind in public. Her biases and opinions like all of ours, are
our own until we unveil them publicly. Her continued public ties
with her vilely racist brother are even
more indicative of her lack of judgment.
It is especially worthy of note that in addition to Walgreens, Home Depot, Food Network,
Smithfield, her publisher, Target, J.C. Penny and Sears the issue was far from
liberal. It was financially conservative , and apparently reflects their lack of
faith in Ms. Deens ability to redeem herself in the public eye, The most significant
proof of the total lack of “Liberal Agenda” conspiracy is that Wal-mart,
the world’s largest retailer and a
company run by generations of rabidly conservative Republicans, dropped her like a hot rock..
So what, then, is this “liberal agenda?” As far as I can determine, the liberal agenda it is the radical idea that all Americans, regardless of an individual’s
personal feelings and biases either way,
deserve equal treatment before the law and in health care and opportunity in society – a level playing
field. Period! Now that I put it in writing I guess I actually can see why the Rabid
Right fears it so much. Equal treatment also extends to marriage,
freedom from religious intrusion into one’s life, freedom from job. housing,
voting discrimination as well. Using the
phrase “liberal agenda” like swear words does much more to describe the emotional
pathology of the speaker than the attitudes of those who espouse it.
Well said and well written in defense of the "liberal agenda." As I had responded to mindless right wing criticism back in January* in defense of "progressives" and what we uphold to be our purpose, the following words from John F. Kennedy’s Profiles In Courage came to mind -- “If by a "Liberal" they mean someone who looks ahead and not behind, someone who welcomes new ideas without rigid reactions, someone who cares about the welfare of the people-their health, their housing, their schools, their jobs, their civil rights and their civil liberties-someone who believes we can break through the stalemate and suspicions that grip us in our policies abroad, if that is what they mean by a "Liberal", then I'm proud to say I'm a "Liberal.”
ReplyDelete*The Villages Daily Sun, January 20, 2013